data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7f76c/7f76cedc038b47570afcf3a782f26486b60d94df" alt=""
Eventually Tara Leddy was going to break.
The junior ace for the Alma College softball team has been a rock all season and particularly brilliant over the past four weeks as she has not allowed a single earned run in her last five starts.
But even the best pitchers cannot be perfect at all times and Leddy's one errant pitch cost her three runs and proved to be the difference Sunday morning at Scots Park.
Needing a win over Adrian College to stay alive in the Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association softball tournament, host Alma College instead could not find any offense to support Leddy and watched as one swing of the bat by Jenna Kloster in the fourth inning turned the tides.
The three-run home run from Kloster was all the scoring the Bulldogs needed in the 3-0 decision, sending top seed Alma College home prematurely and hoping for an at-large bid during today's Division III NCAA Tournament selection show that will take place at noon.
"I think we are still in, but it's all up to how the top seeds in the other conference tournaments do," said Alma College head coach Denny Griffin.
"If we had won this one against Adrian, that would have been the clincher but unfortunately they were a little better than us today. We have a good resume, but you just never know until your name is called."
It was a long wait to get the tournament completed as inclement weather canceled the proceedings on Friday and Saturday.
After going 1-1 on Thursday, the Scots (30-9) needed to defeat Adrian (29-10) and then Trine University twice in order to win the MIAA Tournament title.
The rematch against Trine never transpired.
"I saw a lot of life out of our girls this morning and I don't think the early start played any role," Griffin said. "We came here expecting to play three games and it just didn't work out the way we planned."
As soon as the contest started it had the makings of a pitcher's duel, one in which one bad pitch might be the difference.
That, unfortunately for Alma College, was exactly what happened.
Kelly Eberhardt (20-7) entered the circle Sunday as Adrian College's single-season strikeout leader, a mark she broke in the final regular season doubleheader of the season.
Her abilities in the circle were evident from the get-go as she struck out two in the first to work around a Kelsey Rightenburg single.
Eberhardt then struck out the side in the second and one more in the third with the Scots going down in order both times.
"I tip my hat to Kelly, she pitched a great game," Griffin said. "Our kids said the ball was moving and she mixed her pitches. Tara pitched very well for us too, it was just a couple pitches in that fourth inning she'd like to have back."
Leddy (13-5) matched her counterpart through the first three, striking out four hitters and giving up just one hit.
But then the fourth inning happened, a frame in which Leddy ran into the kind of trouble she had been able to avoid the last three-plus weeks.
A leadoff walk and a one-out single set the table for Kloster, who smacked the ball just over the left field fence to give the Bulldogs a 3-0 advantage.
It ended Leddy's streak of no earned runs at 36 1/3 innings.
"She's been unbelievable for us during these past few weeks and she knows she made a couple of bad pitches that they hit hard," Griffin said of Leddy. "It's tough because we didn't have a lot of highlights offensively and when you can't support your pitcher you aren't going to win games."
After going down in order in the fifth, Alma College appeared it might have a little offensive life left in the top of the sixth.
A leadoff single by nine-hole hitter Dana Fend started things off, while pinch runner Chelsea Jensen moved to second on a groundout.
But with one out, the hardest hit ball by Alma College all day off the bat of Rightenburg was snagged on a line by Bulldogs first baseman Meghan Stevens for the second out.
"Rightenburg laced that ball and they made a tremendous play on it, but who knows what would have happened had we had a couple of runners on base," said Griffin.
Another groundout ended the frame, while the Scots went down in order in the seventh to end it.
Leddy surrendered the three earned runs on four hits with seven strikeouts and two walks over seven innings.
Eberhardt threw seven shutout innings of three-hit ball, striking out nine and walking none.
Rightenburg led Alma College with a single and a stolen base, while Sarah Johnson and Fend had the other two hits.
"Regardless of what happens, we've had a great season and were the conference champions," Griffin said. "Hopefully we get in and have the chance to play some more softball next week."
Trine went on to win the MIAA Tournament title as it topped Adrian College 1-0 in the final.